The Constitutional declares the capital gains tax null and void if it exceeds the profit from the sale of the flat

The Constitutional confirms his setback to capital gains tax, but with nuances. The plenary of the High Court has stated, in a judgment published in full on Wednesday and partially advanced on 31 October, that this municipal levy , which is paid by the seller of a property for the alleged increase in his assets, is confiscatory when it exceeds the net profit obtained. But it does not establish whether it is null also when it is disproportionate to the gain obtained.
The judgment answers a question of unconstitutionality raised by the Administrative Court Number 32 of Madrid, concerning a sale that provided the buyer with a profit of 4,343.67 euros and for which it was required to pay a tax of 3,560 euros. That is, the levy absorbed 89.89% of the profit. The Madrid court then asked the Constitutional Court whether this tax could be considered confiscatory, also in the light of subtracting the costs that the taxpayer had had to bear, the net profit was less than the amount of the levy.
The Constitutional decides that the tax is unconstitutional only when it exceeds the net profit, subtracting the acquisition and transmission costs.
José María Salcedo, a partner in the law firm, considers it debatable that the costs can be taken away from the tax base, since this approach contradicts the doctrine of the Supreme Court. Moreover, he points out that the Constitutional’s calculations are not entirely correct. “You have juggled to make the benefit less than the tax paid, including notary fees, mortgage cancellation expenses that the Supreme in principle does not admit,” he says. “With this, he has avoided resolving the case that had actually been raised with him [tax to pay minimally less than profit] and avoiding setting rules, such as establishing a percentage from which the tax is confiscatory even if there is profit.” Something that happens in other countries.

The municipal capital gains tax – officially, the tax on the increase in the value of lands of an urban nature (IIVTNU) – is one of the most important taxes managed by the Municipalities. It applies to the profit obtained from the sale of a property and is based on the alleged revaluation that the land acquires over the years.
In 2017, the Constitutional Found that this levy is unconstitutional if there are losses for the seller in the sale transaction, considering that the principle of “economic capacity” envisioned by taxpayers in Article 31 of the Constitution is violated.
Almudena Velázquez, lawyer of the platform Reclamador.es, confirms that the judgment published this Wednesday clashes with the doctrine of the Supreme regarding the calculation of the tax base, and recalls that there is another question raised by the same Supreme about the constitutionality of the calculation formula that determines the tax, based on “coefficients that always give gains because they make a forecast for the future” on the revaluation of the land.
That judgment clarifies that “the defect declared is found exclusively in the way of determining the taxable basis and not in that of calculating the tax quota”. Velázquez interprets it as another warning for the legislator to move forward with the reform of this rule, which has been pending since 2017. “It is important to note that once declared unconstitutional, first Paragraphs 107.1, 107.2(a) and 110.4 of the TRLHL by STC 59/2017 of 11 May, and now Article 107.4 TRLHL by this judgment, it is the task of the legislature, in the exercise of its freedom of normative configuration, to adapt the legal regime of the tax to the constitutional requirements set out in one and the other judgment”, the judgment reads.
“Citizens are in a situation of legal insecurity,” velázquez laments, who recalls that the Constitutional judgment published on Wednesday opens the range for review of cases that do not yet have a firm resolution.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Related Posts

Compare